Case 157

The Strip Search Scam

*** Content Warning: sexual assault ***

The evening of April 9, 2004, started as a regular, uneventful shift for employees at a McDonald’s restaurant in Mount Washington, Kentucky. Until 4:56 PM, when the phone rang and the man on the other line introduced himself as Officer Scott. 

According to Officer Scott, a customer had reported having their purse stolen by one of the staff members. He described the employee as a young, petite white woman with dark hair. Management identified the woman in question and called her into the back office, where Officer Scott orders her to undergo a strip search.



Casefile Presents



Research & writing – Erin Munro

Creative direction – Milly Raso

Narration – Anonymous Host



‘Flatline intro’ and ‘Come play with me’ intro and outro –

Audio production – Mike Migas 

Scoring – Mike Migas and Andrew Joslyn



Logo and website design – Paulina Szymanska



Although Casefile episodes are free for all listeners, those who want to support us financially can do so by becoming a member of Patreon, Apple Premium or Spotify Premium. Paid subscribers receive access to exclusive content including behind-the-scenes discussions with the Casefile team, interviews, early releases and ad-free episodes.




A hoax most cruel – The Courier-Journal

Restaurant shift turns into nightmare – ABC News

Strip-Search Case Victim Awarded $6.1 Million – ABC News



Caller nabbed? – The Paducah Sun

Strip-search prank suspect held – The Salt Lake Tribune

Man pleads guilty in hoax case – The Courier-Journal

Hoax victim now opposes plea deal – The Courier-Journal

Man tells hoax victim he’s sorry – The Courier-Journal

Bullitt man pleads guilty in strip-search case – The Courier-Journal

Woman gets probation in Bullitt case – The Courier-Journal

Hoax leads to nationwide search for mysterious caller – The Messenger-Inquirer

Bullitt strip search trial set – The Courier-Journal

Trial begins in case involving strip search at McDonald’s – The Courier-Journal

Hoax victim says she was too scared to flee – The Courier-Journal

Calling card’s link to suspect in Bullitt hoax disputed in testimony – The Courier-Journal

Defense argues hoax call was scam – The Courier-Journal

Jury clears hoax case defendant – The Courier-Journal

Selection of jurors starts in strip case – The Courier-Journal

Strip-search case to begin; $200 million at stake – The Courier-Journal

Lawyer says McDonald’s did all it could to warn workers of sex hoax – The Courier-Journal

Witness: Hoaxer began small, escalated demands – The Courier-Journal

McDonald’s lawyer: Hoax warning inadequate – The Courier-Journal

Strip-search hoax victim testifies on McDonald’s assault – The Courier-Journal

Witness thought of suicide after hoax – The Courier-Journal

McDonald’s witness says hoax victim has mostly recovered after her trauma – The Courier-Journal

McDonald’s official testifies he wasn’t told of previous hoaxes – The Courier-Journal

Defense expert: Hoax helped victim grow – The Courier-Journal

Jury returns to deliberations in McDonald’s strip search case – The Advocate-Messenger

O. gets $6.1 million in strip-search lawsuit – The Courier-Journal

Jury argued over award total, forewoman says – The Courier-Journal

Jury award upheld for victim of strip search – The Courier-Journal

McDonald’s and O. settle strip-search suit – The Courier-Journal



McDonald’s Corporation v L. O., Donna J. Summers and Kim Dockery



The Prank Call part 1 – Pretend

The Prank Call part 2 – Pretend



Primetime segment – ABC News

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This