Case 180

Bill Payne & Billie-Jean Hayworth

“This is going to be the stupidest thing you’ve ever heard. This is going to be the craziest thing you’ve ever heard. There is nothing in your lives or background that has prepared you to understand the Potter family. You have never seen anybody like them.”

When Bill Payne met Billie-Jean Hayworth, his life changed for the better. He drank less, quit partying, and only had eyes for her. When Billie-Jean discovered she was pregnant, Bill was overjoyed. The future for the soon-to-be parents looked bright.
Yet not everyone was happy for the young couple. When nasty comments appeared about the pair online, their hometown of Mountain City, Tennessee was divided. While many residents came to Bill and Billie-Jean’s defence, others embraced the online vitriol being directed at them.
What followed was an unbelievable case that involved a CIA agent, a secret relationship and an impressionable local man named Jamie Curd – all culminating in a double homicide on January 30, 2012. At the centre of the chaos was the Potter family: ‘Buddy’, Barbara, and their daughter, Jenelle.



Casefile Presents



Research & writing – Eileen Ormsby

Creative direction – Milly Raso

Narration – Anonymous Host



‘Flatline intro’ and ‘Come play with me’ intro and outro –

Audio production – Mike Migas 

Music – Mike Migas and Andrew Joslyn



Logo and website design – Paulina Szymanska




State v Marvin Potter

State v Barbara Potter

State v Jenelle Potter



Too Pretty To Live: The Catfishing Murders of East Tennessee – Dennis Brooks



Police Build Case Around 2 Suspects in Murder of Young Couple – ABC News

20/20 episode “Unfriended” – ABC TV, 2015



Ongoing reporting in The Tomahawk, including daily updates of the trials

Archives of the Topix forums for Mountain City (retrieved via the Wayback Machine)

Jenelle Potter’s Myspace page

Crime scene photos





Casefile Presents – Find your new favourite podcast

BetterHelp – Get 10% off your first month of professional counselling with a licensed therapist

Truebill – Take control of your finances and save money

Imperfect Foods – Get 20% off and free shipping on your first order with offer code ‘CASEFILE’

SimpliSafe – Protect your home and your family today. Free security camera, free shipping, free returns and 60 days risk-free trial

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This