Case 354
The Gilgo Beach Serial Killings
*** Content warnings: Sexual assault, rape, femicide ***
[Part 1 of 2]
In the late 2000s, women started going missing after travelling to Long Island, New York. Initially, their disappearances were only noticed by their families, but when a fifth victim named Shannan Gilbert went missing on May 1 2010, the search for her would reveal a series of horrific crimes…
CREDITS
EPISODE
Research & writing – Erin Munro
Narration – Anonymous Host
MUSIC
‘Flatline intro’ and ‘Come play with me’ intro and outro – www.dl-sounds.com
Audio production – Mike Migas
Scoring – Mike Migas
Audio editing – Anthony Telfer
OTHER
Logo and website design – Paulina Szymanska
PREMIUM
Although Casefile episodes are free for all listeners, those who want to support us financially can do so by becoming a member of Patreon, Apple Premium or Spotify Premium. Paid subscribers receive access to exclusive content including behind-the-scenes discussions with the Casefile team, interviews, early releases and ad-free episodes.
RESOURCES
BOOKS
Lost Girls – Robert Kolker
ARTICLES
What we know about the women known as the ‘Gilgo Four’ – CNN
Officer and his dog play key role in hunt for remains – New York Times
Why the search has been so tough – Newsday
Source: Gilgo remains differ – Newsday
Long Island’s other serial killer – Long Island Press
Bodies found at LI beaches – Newsday
A serial killer terrorises Long Island – Newsweek
Who is the Long Island Serial Killer? – CBS News
Identifying another victim, officials raise possibility of a 2nd L.I. killer – New York Times
Investigators believe single serial killer behind Gilgo Beach bodies – NBC New York
Official: Phone records show missing woman on LI – ABC 7
Lost Girls: When women go missing on Long Island some matter, prostitutes don’t – Long Island Press
Body of Shannan Gilbert found in Oak Beach, L.I. – New York Daily News
A serial killer in common – New York Magazine
Shannan Gilbert’s family speaks out – CBS News
Where is Dr Peter Hackett, the mysterious doctor from Lost Girls, now? – Oxygen
Did Long Island serial killer taunt sister of victim? – CBS News
The botched hunt for the Gilgo Beach killer – New York Times
Former police chief arrested in New York state, accused of beating suspect – The Washington Post
The strange rise and violent fall of Long Island’s dirtiest police chief – Vice
Bad cop, worse cop: James Burke and the overwhelming stench of corruption in Suffolk County – Newsweek
Ex-Suffolk County police chief who oversaw Gilgo Beach murder investigation arrested – ABC 7
Did police corruption derail the Long Island Serial Killer investigation? – Rolling Stone
A scandal sent a Long Island police chief to prison. Now it’s brought down the D.A. too – The Washington Post
Shannan Gilbert’s family lawyer says former police chief should be suspect in Gilgo Beach killings – People
Escort places former Suffolk police chief at site of murders – WSHU
Gilgo Beach serial killings: Rex Heuermann charged with 3 murders – Newsday
Dave Schaller came face to face with alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann – CBS News
Gilgo Beach murders: How one man’s tip helped crack the case – ABC 7
A new look at an old clue helps investigators arrest the man accused of Gilgo Beach murders – KSAT.com
The Polygon and the Avalanche: How the Gilgo Beach suspect was found – New York Times
Who is Rex Heuermann, the man who strangled 8 women? – New York Times
In high school, Gilgo Beach suspect was an angry loner, schoolmates say – New York Times
Gilgo Beach suspect’s home held a 279-weapon arsenal and a walk-in vault – New York Times
Is car taken from Long Island Serial Killer’s SC property linked to Charlotte victim? – Charlotte Observer
Long Island serial killer suspect Rex Heuermann indicted in another murder – Oxygen
Gilgo suspect Rex Heuermann’s sick Google searches revealed – New York Post
Before dumping dumping victims at Gilgo Beach, Rex Heuermann tortured them in his Long Island home – A&E
Distinctive initialed belt used to bind Gilgo Beach victim could match Rex Heuermann relatives – New York Post
Accused Gilgo Beach murderer had ‘arsenal’ of up to 300 guns stashed in vault at Long Island home – New York Post
A secret room and a jarring first date: Gilgo Beach murders suspect set off alarm bells – Yahoo
Jessica Taylor, first Gilgo Beach serial killer victim to be identified, was found 20 years ago Wednesday – Long Island Press
Who is Valerie Mack? Accused serial killer charged with murdering woman with ties to Philadelphia – 6ABC
Gilgo Beach murders victim Karen Vergata’s final phone call revealed – Independent
Woman who dated Rex Heuermann said he wouldn’t stop talking about the Gilgo Beach murders – Business Insider
Suspect in Gilgo Beach killings may have started preying on women more than three decades ago – NBC News
Mother of Shannan Gilbert, believed to be Gilgo Beach murder victim, found stabbed to death; other daughter charged in slaying – New York Daily News
Unidentified murder victim dubbed ‘Peaches’ linked to Gilgo Beach killings – Long Island Press
The site where Tanya Denise Jackson was found – OddStops
Florida man charged in 1997 killing of woman once linked to Gilgo Beach murders – AP
Andrew Dykes charged with murder of ‘Peaches’ Tanya Jackson, but not their 3-year-old baby – Long Island Press
Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann sentenced to life in prison without parole – ABC News
Gilgo Beach sentencing: Killer briefly addresses court as angry families speak out – ABC 7
Families of eight women killed confront the Gilgo Beach serial killer – The Guardian
Rex Heuermann admitted he killed 8 women. What about Gilgo Beach’s other bodies? – CNN
OFFICIAL DOCUMENTS
Former Suffolk County police chief indicted on civil rights violation and obstruction conspiracy – FBI & U.S. Attorney’s Office press release
The People of the State of New York again Rex A. Heuermann – Bail application, July 14, 2023
The People of the State of New York again Rex A. Heuermann – Bail application, January 16, 2024
The People of the State of New York again Rex A. Heuermann – Bail application, June 6, 2024
The People of the State of New York again Rex A. Heuermann – Bail application, December 17, 2024
Shannan Gilbert 911 call transcript
DOCUMENTARIES
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer – Netflix
WEBSITES
Crime Timelines – Gilgo Beach and Long Island Serial Killer investigation
VIDEOS
How did police track down Gilgo Beach murders suspect? – CBS News
Melissa Barthelemy’s mother on police failures, victim blaming & justice – Sinister with Josh Zeman
Chilling Gilgo Beach 911 calls released after 12 years – Pix11 News
Full victim impact statements: Gilgo Beach serial killer sentencing – News 12
Amber Costello’s sister confronts Rex Heuermann at his sentencing – Docket Unsealed
Sandra Costilla’s family describes ‘30 years’ of waiting for justice – Docket Unsealed